2

Let's say I come new to the space and I find these three facts:

I just came into the space and found three simple facts that together seem make a rather (alarmingly?) inconsistent landscape (or what did I got wrong?). Are BIP commentators stiff condescending nitpick intelligentsia? Are cold storage vendors reckless brick-and-mortar profit-seeking CEO-wannabe grunts? Am I overthinking this or is this a confusing actual source of cognitive dissonance? If so does such cognitive dissonance scare away any newcomers?

Can you try to help me figure it out, I try to reason like this:

  • Advising against hot wallets seems to make sense as a first measure against exploits.
  • If every cold storage device is based on BIP 39 mnemonics, it sort of speaks that for some reason cold storage vendors don't care too much on BIP comments.
  • The unanimous discourage for implementation note doesn't seem to expand much on particular example posts discouraging implementation.

So why is BIP 39 unanimously discourage for implementation (with or without having to look back to the mailing list, does it make sense to write a little summary here...)?.

2

1 Answer 1

3

BIP 2 provides for comments that can be posted on BIPs on the Bitcoin.it wiki. Currently, all comments about BIP 39 are negative, which is what is summarized as "unanimously discouraged for implementation". All that is needed for that summary to change is for someone to post a positive comment.

Now, the comments mechanism seems to be pretty much completely abandoned, making the summary potentially out of date with reality. I do think it'd be better if it was dropped for that reason, but so far, no new BIP has superseded the mechanism of BIP 2.

Lastly, as far as the contents of your own (apparent) opinion goes, note that opinions against BIP 39 are not necessarily opinions in general against all seed phase based mechanisms, and certainly not opinions in favor of hot wallets (because one can have cold wallets that are not BIP 39 based).

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.