4

From Bitcoin Wiki: Testnet

There have been three generations of testnet. Testnet2 was just the first testnet reset with a different genesis block, because people were starting to trade testnet coins for real money. Testnet3 is the current test network. It was introduced with the 0.7 release, introduced a third genesis block, a new rule to avoid the "difficulty was too high, is now too low, and transactions take too long to verify" problem, and contains blocks with edge-case transactions designed to test implementation compatibility.

I'm interested to know about Testnet(1) and Testnet2: the differences, the reason each version was deprecated (in particular, how/why people were selling TBTCs). I'm interested in the "historical context" as much as I am technical reasons for changing to a new Testnet version.

2
  • 1
    I think this is a duplicate of Has the testnet ever been reset?, but I'm not sure.
    – Nick ODell
    Feb 28, 2015 at 5:37
  • I suppose it is quite similar; I'll rephrase because what I was curious about was the circumstances of resetting; or is it just simply that resetting stops hoarding? Feb 28, 2015 at 7:42

1 Answer 1

2

The testnet networks are very similar to each other. I listed all of the testnet resets here, and it seems like they make the minimum changes necessary to create a new blockchain.

It seems like the testnet3 reset came about because of compatibility issues:

"Mark III" because this is the third genesis block for the testnet. The main reason for the reset is to get a more 'sane' test network; with the BIP16 and BIP30 and testnet difficulty blockchain rule changes the old testnet is a mess, with old clients serving up different, incompatible chains.

(Source.)

The creation of testnet2 predates the Bitcoin mailing list, but given this discussion in #bitcoin-dev, I think it happened because difficulty on testnet was too high:

17:04   slush   btw any chance to reset testnet?
17:05   tcatm   you could use your pool and a modified bitcoind to reset it in about 6 hours
17:05   slush   no, I don't want to connect pool to testnet ;)
17:06   slush   But new genesis block in next release should solve this, right?
17:07   gavinandresen   You talking about possible testnet reset?
17:08   slush   it would be nice. It's practically impossible to 'test' anything on testnet :)
17:08   gavinandresen   If you have two machines you can create your own private testnet
17:09   gavinandresen   ... but you can't test until they've generated at least 100 blocks.
17:10   slush   gavinandresen: agree, but is there any reason for keeping difficulty so high?
17:10   gavinandresen   Nope
[Edited for length.]

(Source.)

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge that you have read and understand our privacy policy and code of conduct.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.