0

Good day.

I've created 2 addresses from the same private key. One address is of course compressed, while the other isn't.

compressed_public_key = "025d9a1a0a5dab7e3e4a84c30a42ddc0d71b2da0fa1f3b99fbda9fc03eb8c75cd5" 
corresponding_address = "mfjRUvWr9QZadpiRnbRfHS4UDSxdR9FE75"

uncompressed_public_key =  "045d9a1a0a5dab7e3e4a84c30a42ddc0d71b2da0fa1f3b99fbda9fc03eb8c75cd535a0b893f20338d37d20eebe2941859dfe53b175f0bb24a27bc77741f0bb8cac"
uncompressed_address = "mi4kMd3HcLUGJSouNdJZ87eUBbi7cNE6C3"

I've also send some coins to each address.

utxo_to_compressed = "963baf6eb615a09afcb05ebcdbd3db05a163994dd2035002477c753ba3281eff"
utxo_to_uncompressed = "08a1286bb379f6eb5151828505b934c1b917201592bb76bd252a53b7a3009b17"

Using bitcore I've created the private_key to sign the transactions and the utxos as follow:

privateKey = new bitcore.PrivateKey(BN, "testnet")

scriptSig =  "76a914" + hashedPubKey + "88ac";

And the hashed public keys are:
1bf398bb044e55f1971e384cc1e6d861dca3adb9 for the uncompressed 
025bafbac8a8a1fcbae04f9a6aa8b6f968c9d145 for the compressed

utxo_compressed = new bitcore.Transaction.UnspentOutput({
    "txId": "08a1286bb379f6eb5151828505b934c1b917201592bb76bd252a53b7a3009b17",
    "outputIndex": 0,
  "address": "mi4kMd3HcLUGJSouNdJZ87eUBbi7cNE6C3",
    "script": scriptSig,
    "satoshis": 5000000000
});

utxo_uncompressed = new bitcore.Transaction.UnspentOutput({
    "txId": "963baf6eb615a09afcb05ebcdbd3db05a163994dd2035002477c753ba3281eff",
    "outputIndex": 0,
  "address": "mfjRUvWr9QZadpiRnbRfHS4UDSxdR9FE75",
    "script": scriptSig,
    "satoshis": 5000000000
});

Signing the compressed utxo isn't a problem. But once I'm trying to sign the uncompressed transaction I receive an error message.

compressedTx = new bitcore.Transaction();
uncompressedTx = new bitcore.Transaction();
compressedTx.from(utxo).to(some output).sign(privateKey); <-This one works fine
uncompressedTx.from(utxo).to(some output).sign(privateKey); <-This one fails
//Some inputs have not been fully signed Use//

In the past, I've sent and redeemed transactions from uncompressed public key (I did it manually, using a simple python code). I can't seem to find any reason why the inputs weren't signed.

I'll highly appreciate any help you might have to offer

1

compressed pubkey and uncompressed one have different hashes. so, your code should be something like:

scriptSig1 = "76a914" + hashedPubKey_1 + "88ac"; 
scriptSig2 = "76a914" + hashedPubKey_2 + "88ac"; 
  • Thank you for your comment. I'm indeed using 2 different hashed public keys. I'll update my original post ASAP to prevent further confusion. – shultz Dec 5 '16 at 13:59
  • Still, even though I'm using different hashed public key, I can't sign the uncompressed tx – shultz Dec 5 '16 at 14:01
0

following code from sign.cpp about line25 now. Seems that the signing from uncompressed keys are purposed disabled in newer core code.

I didn't follow why that was disabled, maybe just to avoid potential hash collision in the future and keep data more standardized.

// Signing with uncompressed keys is disabled in witness scripts
if (sigversion == SigVersion::WITNESS_V0 && !key.IsCompressed())
    return false;
  • Uncompressed keys are only disabled for spending segwit outputs. The reason for disallowing them is to make transactions smaller and is unrelated to hash collisions. – Andrew Chow Jun 13 '18 at 0:06

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.