i am try to spend the coins on a p2sh

first, i generate p2sh and send coins to that p2sh

ECKey clientKey = new ECKey();
ECKey serverKey = new ECKey();
ECKey thirdPartyKey = new ECKey();
List<ECKey> keys = ImmutableList.of(clientKey, serverKey,thirdPartyKey);
Script multisigScript = ScriptBuilder.createP2SHOutputScript(2, keys);
String address = multisigScript.getToAddress(params).toString();

then i send coins to the "address" on testnet3

second, i use the wallet in bitcoinj to watch the "address" and get the tx

WalletAppKit walletAppKit = new WalletAppKit(params, new File("./btcWallet"), "test");
Wallet walletTemp = walletAppKit.wallet();
Address watchAddress = Address.fromString(params, "2NGY4n3Wc2iftWufhUg2MzZtccbkQWgdUiz");
 Set<Transaction> transSet = walletTemp.getTransactions(false);

third, after i get the tx and the output, i want to spend it

TransactionOutput out = ...//output that the second step i get from the tx
Script scriptOut = out.getScriptPubKey()
Coin outValue = Coin.valueOf(10000);
Script redeemScript = ScriptBuilder.createRedeemScript(2, keys);
Address sendAddress = LegacyAddress.fromBase58(params, "2N6846hvswyZEdJ5DuEcjQZPaT5Xwb6PdGT");
Transaction spendTx = new Transaction(params);
spendTx.addOutput(outValue, sendAddress);
TransactionInput input = spendTx.addInput(out);

Sha256Hash sighash = spendTx.hashForSignature(0, redeemScript, Transaction.SigHash.ALL,
ECKey.ECDSASignature cSignature = clientKey.sign(sighash);
ECKey.ECDSASignature sSignature = serverKey.sign(sighash);
TransactionSignature cTransactionSignature = new TransactionSignature(cSignature, Transaction.SigHash.ALL,
TransactionSignature sTransactionSignature = new TransactionSignature(sSignature, Transaction.SigHash.ALL,

Script inputScript = ScriptBuilder.createP2SHMultiSigInputScript(ImmutableList.of(cTransactionSignature, sTransactionSignature), scriptOut);

it have error at "input.verify(out);",Script resulted in a non-true stack: [] [3044022043d0cdddb087c4db2937a3b656c37bf240fd95e16714125c0672875bb18b4c1902200f96e1ec0adc2258e324cbacba598cb72d502a4e3185212dea40c50b365d3fb901] []

i do not kown where my code is wrong and how to solve it.

find a similar problem, but not the same [1]: Errors when building/sending multisig transactions

  • Your second signature in a 2 of 3 multisig should be signing the resulting tx hex from the first signature. Based on a quick glance of your example looks like you are signing the same sighash twice, so it only looks like one key signed.
    – m1xolyd1an
    Dec 24 '19 at 2:09
  • thank you very much,i will try Dec 24 '19 at 2:39
  • how can i sign from the first signature,i change the code like this:Sha256Hash sighash1 = spendTx.hashForSignature(0, redeemScript, Transaction.SigHash.ALL, false); ECKey.ECDSASignature cSignature = clientKey.sign(sighash1); Sha256Hash sighash2 = spendTx.hashForSignature(0, redeemScript, Transaction.SigHash.ALL, false); ECKey.ECDSASignature sSignature = serverKey.sign(sighash2); Dec 24 '19 at 2:54

Based on your example it looks like you are signing the same sighash twice, so it only looks like one key signed.

This example might help: https://github.com/magmahindenburg/MultisigExamples/blob/master/src/se/moar/bitcoin/multisig/MultisigPresentation.java

    // Sign the first part of the transaction using private key #1
    Sha256Hash sighash = spendTx.hashForSignature(0, redeemScript, Transaction.SigHash.ALL, false);
    ECKey.ECDSASignature ecdsaSignature = key1.sign(sighash);
    TransactionSignature transactionSignarture = new TransactionSignature(ecdsaSignature, Transaction.SigHash.ALL, false);

    // Create the sighash2 using the redeem script
    Sha256Hash sighash2 = spendTx.hashForSignature(0, redeemScript, Transaction.sighash2.ALL, false);
    ECKey.ECDSASignature secondSignature;

    // Take out the key and sign the signhash
    ECKey key2 = createKeyFromSha256Passphrase("Super secret key 2");
    secondSignature = key2.sign(sighash2);

    // Add the second signature to the signature list
    TransactionSignature transactionSignarture = new TransactionSignature(secondSignature, Transaction.sighash2.ALL, false);

    // Rebuild p2sh multisig input script
    inputScript = ScriptBuilder.createP2SHMultiSigInputScript(signatureList, redeemScript);

  • Thank you very much to spend time thinking my problem. The example you give is what my code refer and i simplify the code to one function. You give me a direction to solve the problem,the key problem maybe is you said "signing the same sighash twice", i will try later. Thank you again. Dec 26 '19 at 6:24
  • sorry for that i can not click the useful button for my low reputation Dec 27 '19 at 2:33

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.