Questions tagged [consensus]
Questions about the consensus system of Bitcoin and the protocol rules that are consensus critical.
279
questions
5
votes
1
answer
97
views
Is a Taproot output with unparseable x-only pubkey unspendable?
The first output of f33ead0ef49900a782b83eede071f9b5f12142d2a403092452fd6ecf99f153c8 can't be parsed with secp256k1_xonly_pubkey_parse. [0]
Does that mean there's no way to spend it? I.e. there's no ...
- 1,014
5
votes
2
answers
581
views
How many blocks per second can sustainably be created using a time warp attack?
In a time warp attack, an attacker can reduce proof of work difficulty to its minimum, which allows even a single piece of modern mining equipment to create large numbers of blocks per second. ...
- 12.1k
2
votes
2
answers
195
views
Why does an activated soft fork not invalidate the blockchain?
In Antonopolous’s Mastering Bitcoin 2nd Ed p263, it says in the example of the BIP-34 soft fork activation the following:
"When 95% (950 of the most recent 1000 blocks) are version 2, version 1 ...
-5
votes
2
answers
200
views
Is PoW an indispensable component in blockchain?
There is an argument that if the Proof-of-Work (PoW) mechanism is removed from the Bitcoin network or if the puzzle does not have a sufficient level of difficulty proportional to the computing power ...
- 1,126
0
votes
1
answer
91
views
Consensus Question
With all the recent developments of the spammers and those who want to filter them. I have a few things I don't get. They mention the bug that wasn't fixed (CVE-2023-50428). As I understand, this &...
6
votes
3
answers
733
views
What are the risks of running a pre-SegWit node (0.12.1)?
Many in the anti-spam faction have contemplated running a pre-SegWit node. But they're told that it is an insecure downgrade and a detrimental idea. So,
Is it safe to assume that Bitcoin is not soft-...
- 433
1
vote
1
answer
120
views
What are ALL the consensus rules?
I asked this question before, and it was quickly locked and pointed to a thread about mempool policy... yet my question remains unanswered.
Let it be known, I don't want to know what policy is [or is ...
- 37
1
vote
1
answer
164
views
Are there plans to make a script invalid if there is more than one element left in the stack?
In BIP62, it was proposed to make a script invalid if there was more than one element left in the stack after execution. This proposal was eventually withdrawn.
From what I read, some people have ...
- 191
0
votes
1
answer
102
views
Can the hash of UTXO set be part of the bitcoin block header and consensus rules and in which cases?
This question doesn't have much logic in "reality", it's more theoretical about whether something can or cannot be part of consensus rules and in which cases.
I know that the consensus rule ...
- 990
3
votes
1
answer
251
views
Are consensus rules allowed to be associated with off-chain information and how is the locktime consensus rule?
In answer to one of my previous questions, Pieter Wuille wrote that the +2h rule for block acceptance cannot be a consensus rule because it is based on comparing block timestamp with information that ...
- 990
4
votes
1
answer
164
views
Why isn't the upper bound (+2h) on the block timestamp set as a consensus rule?
Why isn't the +2h acceptance rule part of the consensus? Of course, then it couldn't be based on network-adjusted time + 2h because, in edge cases, one part of the network might accept something while ...
- 990
0
votes
1
answer
110
views
Is the maximum target a consensus rule?
What is "difficulty" and how it relates to "target"? states that the largest possible target value (max target value) is:
...
- 990
0
votes
0
answers
65
views
Lib bitcoinconsensus verification returns SCRIPT_ERR_INVALID_STACK_OPERATION on a P2SH multisig output
I tried to verify an old transaction 6a26d2ecb67f27d1fa5524763b49029d7106e91e3cc05743073461a719776192 P2SH multisig input 0 using lib bitcoinconsensus and I got SCRIPT_ERR_INVALID_STACK_OPERATION.
...
- 216
5
votes
1
answer
262
views
What is the logic (if there is) behind linking the nSequence and nLockTime?
The nSequence transaction field was originally intended for a replacement logic, but since it was never well thought out, it was never implemented. However, it has been implemented since the beginning ...
- 990
3
votes
1
answer
151
views
What does nVersion represent in Bitcoin transaction?
Have a few questions about the nVersion field in the transaction serialization format and they are related to the purpose of this field.
What does this field tell us? In the sense that if it is ...
- 990
0
votes
2
answers
46
views
Are the blocks produced by different nodes in the network comparable in terms of the order of transactions contained in them?
Having a transaction from person A to B and another transaction from person C to D that both took place in more or less the same time I assume that there might be a situation in which different nodes ...
- 133
0
votes
2
answers
154
views
Miners setting timestamps up to 2h into the Future
When a miner adds the Timestamp to a block template, it must satisfy two conditions:
Timestamp must be greater than the Median Timestamp of the previous 11 blocks
Timestamp must be less than its ...
- 65
3
votes
2
answers
614
views
Undefined opcodes in bitcoin core defined as "Synonyms for OP_RETURN" in rust-bitcoin
In rust-bitcoin, opcodes past the 0xba opcode are named as such: OP_RETURN_187, OP_RETURN_188, ..., OP_RETURN_254. Their description is all the same: Synonym for OP_RETURN. The definition for ...
4
votes
2
answers
601
views
Is there a well defined last block?
It's fairly well known when the last bitcoin will be mined, but is there a well defined last block?
By that I mean, is there a block height H after which Bitcoin Core nodes will refuse to accept any ...
- 147
0
votes
1
answer
83
views
Is there a way to participate in bitcoin consensus (tx, block, mining, etc.) verification without downloading the ledger?
It seems like theoretically new blocks could be determined from the list of addresses and the amounts possessed by each address, where maintaining the blockchain would be optional and mostly for ...
- 103
0
votes
1
answer
43
views
is consensus needed when double spend attacks cannot happen(assume ideal case)
Suppose double spend attacks cannot happen(assume senders, miners etc are all ideal actors) in a network like BTC for cryptocurrency transactions. I am assuming still fork can happen if two miners ...
- 103
3
votes
3
answers
756
views
Why does everyone say that soft forks restrict the existing ruleset?
I understand that a key element of a soft fork is that legacy nodes will accept transactions from updated nodes. This is essentially the whole point of a soft fork as opposed to a hard fork.
But ...
- 395
2
votes
1
answer
69
views
why not change bitcoin consensus code to reject transactions sent to previously used addresses?
Bitcoin has a growing issue of UTXO dust. Usually this dust occurs from companies trying to track bitcoin use, by sending dust or small transactions to previously used addresses.
There is almost no ...
- 330
0
votes
0
answers
77
views
Looking for Source of an Old Idea About Subdividing Satoshis
I remember seeing an old idea but unfortunately I didn't bookmark it and now I'm struggling to find the source again. Maybe someone will remember it and be able to point me to the source?
It was ...
- 1,045
2
votes
1
answer
859
views
What are Bitcoin's transaction and script limits?
What are the limits of different transactions and scripts (by consensus and standardness)?
Some stack exchange questions discuss some of them (but not all) and all these are scattered around.
What is ...
- 2,540
1
vote
1
answer
72
views
Is the nVersion=3 policy proposal introducing additional policy rules and going against the policy principle to only relax policy rules?
In the PR review club on "nVersion=3 and Package RBF" (February 22nd 2023) glozow stated:
But in policy we want to strictly loosen rules. Otherwise we could accidentally censor transaction ...
- 15.7k
3
votes
1
answer
91
views
Do nodes accept non-standard output scripts in a mined block?
As I understand, transactions with non-standard output scripts won't be propagated through the network. I'm wondering if I were to mine a block with weird transactions whether it would be accepted by ...
- 173
3
votes
1
answer
281
views
Does the coinbase transaction have inputs?
I was wondering if I can add dummy data into a coinbase transaction’s inputs.
Is it possible to do this? Can you insert invalid input scripts into a coinbase transaction? Can you add multiple inputs ...
- 173
3
votes
3
answers
247
views
Does version of Bitcoin Core determine my consensus?
As far as (voting) on the network?
I run a full node, but do not mine.
I hear people say we have a choice when changes are made.
Is it the version of Core that determines that?
5
votes
2
answers
937
views
Why can the CHECKMULTISIG bug not be solved?
I was reading Mastering Bitcoin and I read about a bug in CHECKMULTISIG. If the starting ideas of this command should work like this
<Signature B><Signature C> M <Public key A><...
- 305
1
vote
1
answer
73
views
Does Bitcoin need future consensus change upgrades or could a billion people use Bitcoin today?
Do Bitcoin Core and other base-layer implementations necessarily need further upgrades in order to become sufficiently fast and efficient to process the volume of transactions that you and others ...
- 15.7k
7
votes
2
answers
544
views
Why exactly would adding further divisibility to bitcoin require a hard fork?
There are quite a few threads already on this topic, but they all focus on the necessity or possibility for such a change. I understand that, even though it is difficult and would obviously require ...
- 404
0
votes
3
answers
89
views
What is the use of longest chain consensus rule?
I want to know Couldnt a chain be hardcoded in the bitcoin rules itself? Only so and so chain can be used. During the early days of bitcoin, I know a small group of enthusiasts were miners. And they ...
2
votes
1
answer
58
views
Can you attack the network in a UASF-way?
Let's say that an attacker wants to deploy a softfork, that isn't desired by the majority of the Bitcoin users. Can he enforce that softfork in a UASF-way, essentially flooding the network with nodes ...
- 433
2
votes
1
answer
128
views
persistence of the RBF bit in post-fullrbf chain
In case consensus decided to ignore pro-zeroconf nodes (in case that is or can be a thing),
then what's the point of having the RBF bit in a transaction, if everything in the system is enforcing RBF (...
- 852
3
votes
2
answers
367
views
Do non-Segwit nodes reject Segwit transactions with invalid signature?
As far as I can tell, non-Segwit nodes receive anyone-can-spend transactions, and thus come with no signature to validate. If a miner included a Segwit transaction to a block with invalid signature, ...
- 433
0
votes
0
answers
13
views
consensus on the moving average [duplicate]
I research on consensus and need a forced delay between submittability of new blocks.
In bitcoin you use stochastics + processor clock speed. This allows you to choose an expected forced delay, which ...
4
votes
1
answer
395
views
Is every BIP actually a small fork?
What precisely do we consider as fork?
It seems that every BIP can be seen as a fork, at least a soft fork since a lot of BIPs indeed are backward compatible. How big or impactful something has to be ...
- 57
2
votes
3
answers
77
views
Relation between PoW and integrity?
I'm pretty new to the Blockchain technology. In a video that I watched, the lecturer talked about Consensus Algorithms and said that they're used for maintaining the integrity of the blockchain.
Then ...
- 21
1
vote
1
answer
174
views
what guarantee that miners will only include valid transactions in a block?
So, miners, if I got it right, before inserting a transaction into the Mempool, will request an arbitrary number of confirmations of full nodes that will search the entire blockchain to see if a ...
0
votes
1
answer
49
views
The competitive practicality of Bitcoin
Bitcoin is to be trustless by the thousands of nodes, but is this no more trustless than the Federal Reserve system? An account size in 8b on each device is a feasible alternative with absolute ...
3
votes
1
answer
221
views
When was the 10,000 B limit for scripts introduced?
The file src/script/script.h defines a MAX_SCRIPT_SIZE of 10,000 B. Among other instances, the MAX_SCRIPT_SIZE is used in the IsUnspendable() check, which allows us to avoid adding outputs with ...
- 76.9k
0
votes
1
answer
88
views
Would a consensus algorithm like the one I describe work?
Given n nodes(miners/validators),
Every unspent transaction output is broadcasted to all n nodes.
Each node will select a batch of transactions and add it to their
block. The specific mechanism of ...
- 9
1
vote
1
answer
200
views
Is there code in libsecp256k1 that theoretically should be moved to the main Core codebase?
In this question on libsecp256k1 Pieter Wuille stated:
libsecp256k1 provides implementations for all kinds of operations that involve private keys, public keys, or both. That includes key generation (...
- 15.7k
1
vote
1
answer
187
views
Is the removal of Bitcoin checkpoints considered a hard-fork?
The value of DEFAULT_CHECKPOINTS_ENABLED is true and changing it will allow nodes using the default settings to accept blocks that would be currently rejected during a potential reorg. Is this change ...
- 294
1
vote
0
answers
48
views
When was proof of stake theorized?
Hi l've seen a while ago that Proof of stake concensus mechanism was theorized a while ago (before proof of work) in distributed systems. But I can't find any source of that, while searching 'proof of ...
- 81
8
votes
2
answers
602
views
Was the addition of OP_NOP codes in Bitcoin 0.3.6 a hard or soft fork?
I'm doing some deeper research into historical consensus changes and it seems like most folks consider the addition of the OP_NOP codes to be a hard fork. Here's the diff for their addition: https://...
- 171
2
votes
1
answer
78
views
Why is the intersection of two quorums must be greater than N/3 when proving streamlet?
Why is the intersection of two quorums must be greater than N/3 when proving Streamlet, a blockchain consensus protocol [BY Chan, Elaine Shi, 2020]?
In Streamlet, honest node vote for proposed block ...
- 35
-1
votes
1
answer
96
views
In future will multiple widely used implementations around libbitcoinkernel be an overall net positive or net negative for the ecosystem?
Assuming the libbitcoinkernel subproject of Bitcoin Core is completed and successfully/safely extracts the consensus engine out of Bitcoin Core will having multiple widely used alternative ...
- 15.7k
3
votes
2
answers
191
views
Is there a consensus as to what is meant by 'Nakamoto Consensus'?
I sometimes hear that bitcoin's key innovation was the Nakamoto Consensus, which solves the double-spend problem without the need for trusted third-party intermediaries.
I take Nakamoto Consensus to ...
- 377